*Spits out coffee on morning paper* What?!
Ninja Gaiden and Dead or Alive mastermind Tomonobu Itagaki surprised the gaming industry not only when he announced that he’s leaving Tecmo, but is also suing the company for “unpaid completion bonuses” and his former boss Yoshimi Yasuda for “unreasonable and disingenuous statements.”
Yasuda told Itagaki that “If you are dissatisfied with the decision not to pay the bonuses, either quit the company or sue it”. This seems to be the reason why Itagaki sued (AND quit) the company. However, if everything he said is true, he really is in the position to sue. Not only was he denied of the pay he deserves: he was also humiliated to his subordinates and colleagues.
However, Tecmo, Itagaki, and his whole team are not the only ones to suffer. According to Itagaki’s message to his fans, Ninja Gaiden II and Dead or Alive 4 seems to be the titles’ last hurrah.
To All Game Fans,
I truly feel sorry to all the fans of the games I have made. NINJA GAIDEN 2, which will launch on the 3rd of June will be the last NINJA GAIDEN I will create. I will also never be able to make DEAD OR ALIVE 5. I regret the circumstances that have forced me to leave Tecmo, where I had worked for so many years, and I regret the disappointment this will cause my fans.
However, I can no longer continue to work with President Yoshimi Yasuda, a man who chooses not to honor promises even when he is able to do so.
I truly hope that nothing like this happens again in the future.
Tecmo Co., Ltd. Creative Officer
Leader, Team NINJA
Tomonobu Itagaki”
To bring light to any questions still unanswered, here’s the complete statement of Itagaki as to why he resigned and why he’s suing:
“I, Tomonobu Itagaki, hereby announce that on the 14th of May 2008 I filed a complaint in the Tokyo District Court against Tecmo Co., Ltd. for unpaid completion bonuses, and against the President of Tecmo, Yoshimi Yasuda, for such unlawful acts as unreasonable and disingenuous statements made towards me, claiming damages in total of 148 million yen. I also announce that this complaint was delivered to the defendants on May 22nd of the same year.
In addition, I hereby announce that I have today submitted a letter of resignation to Tecmo Co., Ltd. stating that I will resign as of the 1st of July, 2008.
Before the start of development on DEAD OR ALIVE 4, Tecmo Co., Ltd. had agreed to pay a completion bonus to me for this Xbox 360 title, which I produced. However, when the time came for the actual payment, Tecmo Co., Ltd. went against its previous agreement and refused payment. President Yoshimi Yasuda chose not only to violate this agreement, but also turned defiant, telling me “if you are dissatisfied with the decision not to pay the bonuses, either quit the company or sue it.” In addition, he made demeaning remarks about me to my subordinates and colleagues, causing me significant emotional distress and worsening my personal relationships and work environment. Thus, I have no choice but to resign from Tecmo Co., Ltd.
The conduct of Tecmo Co., Ltd. and its president Yoshimi Yasuda towards me has been unbefitting of a publicly-listed company.
I have filed this lawsuit with a strong intent to question the social responsibility of Tecmo Co., Ltd. and its President Yoshimi Yasuda, as well as condemning them for their unjust acts. Today, in addition to announcing the reasons for this lawsuit, I make clear my reasons for resigning.
This is not the first time Itagaki faced a controversy inside Tecmo. Last November 2006, one of his co-workers filed a lawsuit against him because of sexual abuse. The court however found him not guilty through the help of Tecmo’s investigations that found the accusation was only because of the female employee’s personal frustrations. Both As a result of this, Itagaki and the female employee were both demoted due to mixing “personal affairs with their corporate responsibilities.”
W-h J: Now, all we have to do is to wait for Yasuda’s reply to Itagaki’s statements. I’ll keep an eye on that for sure and post any findings here. But hey, one thing’s for sure. Itagaki’s resignation will surely hurt Tecmo’s performance, since Ninja Gaiden and Dead or Alive are two of their cash cows. Should the company continue to release succeeding titles under these games, I can foresee heavy criticisms from the gaming world comparing the games under the new director with “What Itagaki should’ve done.”
(Sources: Gaming Today, Wikipedia)